【2008】日本丨政黨政治問題



題目拆解



參考答案(中文版)

(a) 根據資料C,經濟擴張對日本社會有什麼影響?(2分)


考生表現

表現良好。大部分考生能指出經濟擴張對日本社會的影響。

評分準則

例:

- 工商業中產階級有所發展


* 註:直接引錄原文而沒有使用自己文字作答,僅得1分

參考答案

經濟擴張導致中產階級人數增加。 參考資料C,作者指出「經濟擴張的結果之一」就是讓資本家的數目上升,造成大量「工商業中產階級」出現,確為經濟發展的影響。

(b) 除了透過壓力團體以外,日本的中產階級以什麼方法保護其利益?試引用資料C一項線索,支持你的答案。(1+1分)


考生表現

表現良好。大部分考生能根據資料指出日本中產階級與政黨建立聯繫以保護其利益。惟少部分考生只抄淇部分原文,且錯誤理解為與商界勾結,故未能得分。

評分準則

方法: - 與政黨建立聯繫 線索: - 「但更有可能取得實效的則是政黨,它們與商界關係密切。」

參考答案

中產階級與政黨建立聯繫來保障其利益。 參考資料C,作者形容政黨跟商界「關係密切」,表示他們經常往來,結果讓商界影響力達到「任何政府均難以漠視的地位」,意味著中產階級拉攏政治家,藉此保障他們的利益。

(c) 資料C能否充分反映日本政黨政治因何最終於1930年代失敗?試參考資料C,並就你所知,解釋你的答案。(7分)


考生表現

表現良好。大部分考生能運用資料及個人史識解釋政黨於1930年代失敗之因。惟少部分考生不了解關鍵詞「充分反映」,以致答案片面,作答時只引用資料內容或個人所知,因而失分。

評分準則

L1 答案片面(僅運用資料相關史實)或持「充分」觀點。 [最多4分] L2 能同時運用資料相關史實;能清楚闡明觀點。 [最多7分]

資料

例:

- 日本在疹黨派主義、無綱無紀以及貪污腐敗。 - 政黨領袖沒有嘗試掌握恰當的技巧。 - 政黨領袖甚為保守。 個人所知 例:

- 日本沒有民主和憲政的傳統。 - 政黨政府與西方列強合作的政策被軍方視為積弱的標誌。 - 全球經濟大衰退及極權主義的興起,減低了民主的魅力。

參考答案

資料未能充分反映政黨政治失敗的原因。 資料C指出政黨跟資本家互相勾結,如作者形容彼此「關係密切」,政治家致力於維護商人利益,結果中產階級影響力「達至任何政府均難漠視的地位」,顯示政治家貪污腐敗,未能以民為作首要考慮,終導致其失敗。 資料C指出中產階級崛興參與政治,如作者指他們「擔起直接的政治角色」,並通過「壓力團體的方式尋求影響政府的觀點和具體決定」,力求將力益最大化,結果國民利益受損,同時政治家未力改善民心而失去支持,使其失敗告終。 更甚,資料C指政黨「無綱無紀」而且「貪污腐敗」,政黨領袖亦欠缺個人特色,「沒有嘗試去掌握恰當的技巧」來爭取民心,使之「政黨並未能取得廣泛的民眾支持」,招致其於1930年代失敗。 然而,部分原因資料沒有提及。 就我所知,政黨政治家未能有效處理經濟危機,包括關東大地震(1923)、銀行危機(1927)和經濟大衰退(1929)等,更甚造成超過300萬人失業,民怨沸騰,讓他們不得民心失敗告終。 而且,政黨政治家形象軟弱,面對列強欺壓選擇妥協,如參與華盛頓會議(1921-1922)和倫敦海軍會議(1930),同意日本交還中國山東利益並限制海軍擴展,有損日本利益和形象,日人對此大感失望,失去選民支持的政黨亦於1930年代失敗。 最後,政黨政治家貪污腐敗,自1918年原敬擔任首相開始,至1932年換閣高達11次,換言之平均每個首相任期不多於3年,更甚他們與財閥勾結,如1924年違反選舉法個案就高達15000宗,政治家形象負面難以吸引民眾支持,最終於1930年代失敗告吹。


參考答案(英文版)

(a) According to Source C, what was the impact of economic expansion on Japanese society? (2 marks)


Candidates’ Performance

Performance was good. Most candidates were able to point out the impact of economic expansion of Japanese society.

Marking Scheme

e.g.

- The industrial and commercial middle class grew.


* One mark only for direct citation without paraphrasing

Suggested Answer

Economic expansion led to the increase of size of the middle class. According to source C, it is stated that “one result of the expansion of the economy” was that the number of capitalists increased, hence the “industrial and commercial middle class” expanded, all of which were the impacts of economic expansion.

(b) Besides acting as pressure groups, what means did the Japanese middle class adopt to protect its interests? Cite one clue from Source C to support your answer. (1+1 marks)


Candidates’ Performance

Performance was good. Most candidates were able to refer to the Source in pointing out that the Japanese middle class linked itself to the political parties in order to protect its interests. However, a few candidates merely copied from the Source and misread the Source as asserting collaboration between merchants and the government, hence scoring no marks.

Marking Scheme

Means [1 mark] :

- Establishing links with political parties Clue [1 mark] : - ‘But potentially more effective were the political parties, with which business had close links’

Suggested Answer

The Japanese middle class established connections with political parties to protect its interest. According to source C, the author describes political parties and business as having “close links”, meaning that they were closely related to each other, the influence of the business rose to a level that “no government could afford to ignore”, middle class attempted to protect their interest by developing good relations with politicians.

(c) Does Source C adequately reflect why party politics in Japan failed eventually in the 1930s? Explain your answer with referenced to Source C and using your own knowledge. (7 marks)


Candidates’ Performance

Performance was good. Most candidates were able to use the Source and their own knowledge in explaining why party politics in Japan failed in the 1930s. however, some candidates did not understand the key phrase ‘adequately reflect’, and used either the Source or their own knowledge only, hence losing marks.

Marking Scheme

L1 Lopsided (merely referring to the Source or citing relevant historical fact) or holding the view of ‘adequate’. [max. 4] L2 Refer to both the Source and cite relevant historical facts; clearly state the viewpoint. [max. 7]


Source: e.g.

- There were factionalism, unruliness and corruption. - The party leaders made little attempt to cultivate the appropriate skills. - The party leaders were conservative. Own knowledge e.g.

- Japan did not have a tradition of democracy and constitutionalism. - The party government’s policy of cooperating with the Western powers was considered by the militarists as a sign of weakness. - The appeal of democracy subsided after the Great Depression and the rise of totalitarianism.

Suggested Answer

The source was inadequate in reflecting the reasons of the failure of party politics in Japan in the 1930s. Source C states that parties colluded with capitalists, as the author describes them of having a “close link”, politicians safeguarded the interest of businessmen, hence the influence of the middle class reached a “position in society that no government could afford to ignore”. Politicians corrupted and failed to prioritize people’s interest, which eventually led to the failure of party politics. Source C also shows that middle class actively engaged in politics, some of them even held a “direct political role”, who “acted as pressure groups that sought to influence the government’s outlook and specific decisions”, the middle class harmed common people’s interest while maximizing their own interest, meanwhile, politicians also failed to gain popular support, therefore party politics failed. In addition, source C criticizes parties of being “unruly” and “corrupt”, party leaders lacked distinct personal style, they “made little attempt to cultivate the appropriate skills” to win support from people, parties “failed to build up any popular support”, hence party politics failed in 1930s. However, the source fails to reflect some other reasons. According to my own knowledge, politicians failed to address to economic crisis efficiently, for instance there were The Great Kanto Earthquake in 1923, Bank Crisis in 1927 and the Great Depression in 1929, 3 million people were unemployed and discontent emerged among people, therefore parties could not win support from people and failed eventually. Furthermore, the image of politicians was feeble, they chose to compromise in face of superpower’s suppression, for instance in the Washington Conference (1921-1922) and London Naval Conference (1930), Japan was demanded to return its interest in ShanDong in China, its naval development was also limited, all of which undermined Japanese national glory and interest, Japanese people were disappointed, finally parties lost support and failed in 1930s. Last but not least, party politicians were corrupt, ever since Hara Takashi became Prime Minister in 1918, the cabinet was dismissed 11 times until 1932, in other words, the average term of each Prime Minister did not exceed 3 years. Party politicians even colluded with Zaibatsu, for example reported cases of violating the Election Law were up to 15000 in 1924, the negative image of politicians could hardly win popular support, hence party politics failed in 1930s.

Recent Posts

See All

【2011】一戰丨巴爾幹半島

題目拆解 參考答案(中文版) (a)(i) 根據漫畫家,巴爾幹地區的形勢是否嚴峻?參考資料D,解釋你的答案。(3分) 考生表現 表現良好。很多考生能夠指出巴爾幹地區的形勢嚴峻。他們亦能以資料作答。 評分參考 L1 能描述有關形勢,但未能作出有效解釋。 [最多1分] L2能描述有關形勢,亦能參考資料D作出有效解釋。 [最多3分] 巴爾幹地區的形勢︰ 例︰ - 巴爾幹地區的形勢是嚴峻的。 解釋︰

【2011】中國丨革命比改革

題目拆解 參考答案(中文版) (a)從資料A指出漫畫家對中國憲政改革所持的看法。參考資料A,解釋你的答案。(3分) 考生表現 表現欠佳。頗多考生誤以為「看法」即「態度」,因而答案與題旨不符。 評分準則 L1 能指出看法,但未能作出任何有效的解釋。 [最多1分] L2 能指出看法,亦未參考資料A作出有效的解釋。 [最多3分] 看法︰ 例︰ - 清廷將不能學到外國憲政的精髓 解釋︰ 例︰ - 漫畫

【2010】二戰丨希特拉崛興

題目拆解 參考答案(中文版) (a) 資料D中的歷史人物叫什麼名字?從資料D中引用一項線索,支持你的答案。(1+1分) 考生表現 表現良好。大部分考生能指出資料所示漫畫人物的名字,並引用線索說明。部分英文卷考生不明白historical figure一詞的意思,以為題目問及某一件歷史事件,因而未能得分。 評分準則 歷史人物(1分)︰ - 希特拉 線索(1分)︰ 例子︰ - 他是「納粹黨」的領導